Where One Freedom Ends and Another Begins
Freedom to exercise one’s own religion is NOT the same as freedom to stuff that religion down others’ throats. This is what the right-wing Christians have not understood about the Supreme Court decision on gay marriage. No one is forcing them to marry each other–and they do not have the right to keep others from marrying the ones they love, just because their religion doesn’t agree.
When my family was kosher, I went to private Jewish schools (yeshivas). It may have been that part of my parents’ reasons was to keep me away from the “corrupting” influence of non-kosher food.
This post is inspired by a report of a Canadian mayor telling Muslim parents the schools would not stop serving pork–a report that was a hoax (which took about seven seconds to determine). But just because the report was false (and probably motivated by someone seeking to stir up religious divisions) doesn’t mean we shouldn’t talk about the underlying issue: when does one person’s freedom stop and another’s start?
I am a vegetarian and I would never say to a school system, “don’t serve meat because it is offensive to me.” On the contrary, it is offensive to me when someone tells me I can’t eat the food I want because that food offends them, and I wouldn’t presume to make those choices for others. Sure, I wish more people would turn vegetarian, and I can list a dozen reasons why vegetarianism is good for the planet and good for our bodies.
I will say (and have said), “please don’t bring meat into a potluck at my vegetarian house.” A parent offended that foods he/she doesn’t eat are served in the cafeteria has other choices. There are schools where no pork is served–in fact, I know for certain that pork is not served at any Orthodox yeshiva or Islamic or Seventh Day Adventist school. It would be offensive if the Muslim kids and Orthodox Jewish kids and vegetarian kids attending public school were *forced* to eat pork. But it should not be offensive to sit in a cafeteria where others are eating it.
Lois Carter Crawford liked this on Facebook.
James Pilant liked this on Facebook.
Uh-huh. I am guessing whoever cooked this one up “had a dog in that fight.”
D. Dina Friedman liked this on Facebook.
Márcio Nascimento Costa Carvalho liked this on Facebook.
Dorothy Molstad liked this on Facebook.
Lew Holzman liked this on Facebook.
Kathy Rapp liked this on Facebook.
Bobby Cookie Hirtle liked this on Facebook.
Justin Cascio liked this on Facebook.
Richard A Adams liked this on Facebook.
Carrie Hemenway liked this on Facebook.
“… the report was false (and probably motivated by someone seeking to stir up religious divisions)..” Quebec has been working through some interesting ethnicity- and religion-based, um, discussions. The key is that they are working through them, which is why these kinds of hoaxes are unfortunate.
Bobby Cookie Hirtle you may find this post especially relevant to your recent convo with your Uncle Jim.
Well said. The distinction you make is vital.
Thank you.
Great analogy, Dinah Kudatsky.
Shel, I’m sure I stole it – but great minds think alike! 😉
Iask Robert liked this on Facebook.
Dinah Kudatsky liked this on Facebook.
Tish Grier liked this on Facebook.
It’s like someone saying, you can’t eat that donut because I’m on a diet.
Margaret Dubin liked this on Facebook.